This is one of those posts where I might have gotten a bit carried away. But that title about jail comes from one of the comments I got when I posted some quotes from Education Secretary, Arne Duncan, on Twitter and Facebook yesterday. The national education leader visited two Denver schools on Tuesday, and to an apparently unsympathetic room of about 400 middle and high school students,
Duncan said American schools should be open six days a week, at least 11 months a year, to improve student performance. (Gandy)
You’re competing for jobs with kids from India and China. I think schools should be open six, seven days a week; 11, 12 months a year.
I do not know enough about the school (Bruce Randolph) that Duncan seems to be holding up as a model for the nation, for an opinion. But the two statements, attributed to the education leader, not only make my blood boil — but they are simply “Dead Wrong!”
Arnie Duncan was nominated to the Secretary of Education post by President Barack Obama in mid-December last year, and smarter men than me immediately called foul (See Gary Stager’s “What Do Arne Duncan & Paul Bremer Have in Common?). I wanted to give Duncan the benefit of the doubt, but all doubt’s gone now. We’ve gotten no where and we’re going nowwhere, especially if we are going to extend the sentencing of our children.
One commenter of my Facebook posts said,
..the competition we have vs. India and China (2 Million … Minutes) is an impossible task to overcome. Those are the best of the best compared to our better kids.
I would extend this mismatch to suggest that it isn’t simply that we’re comparing their best apples to our better apples. First of all, you’re not going to win the blue ribbon at the county fair by leaving your apple pie in the oven longer. And secondly, why not grow oranges instead. Doesn’t a global market place need diversity of talents and skills — not everyone trying to best each other on the same narrow array of standards.
But we’re not talking about fruit are we? We’re talking about our children. ..and let’s face it, we’re talking about nothing less than institutionalizing “child labor” to satisfy a failed belief that higher standardized test scores will reliably lead to a stronger economy, more prosperous citizens, and a vibrant democracy. What it leads to is boredom, ca lapsing morale among our best teachers, children without passion, children dropping out, and a growing and prospering testing industry.
I was so incredibly lucky to have gone to school when I did. Even though I did poorly on tests, was not conscientious about homework, blah blah blah (we didn’t diagnose leaning disabilities (diversities) back then). I had wise teachers who said, “He’s bright and he can learn anything he wants to learn.” My parents didn’t worry.
My son, who’s not A.D.D., still performed poorly, because he was bored. He didn’t care. He wasn’t drinking the kool aid. He spent his time and attention with his music. I remember when a middle school math teacher refused to sign off on his enrolling in more advanced math classes in high school. She urged us to keep him out of math. The cynic in me is convinced that continued poor math performance wouldn’t have been good for the school.
We put him in Math and he performed poorly — until he approached his senior year and realized that his grades would prevent him from earning that music scholarship he need for his music school of choice. So during his senior year, he out-performed, in calculus, classmates who’d already been accepted at MIT.
Now if you think that the moral of this story is “making kids want to do well in Math will result in better performance,” then you’re wrong. The moral of the story is that if my son finally wants a job, where he needs to know Calculus — then he’ll learn calculus. You see,
Anyone who can master something that he or she is passionate about,
Can learn anything!
Bring passion back into education — and kick out the standards!
..and while you’re at it, kick the amateurs out too!
Gandy. Sara. “Education Secretary says kids need more school ,” 9News.Com 8 Apr 2009. 9 Apr 2009 <http://www.9news.com/news/article.aspx?storyid=113300>.
Powered by ScribeFire.
About the Author: 35 year educator, programmer, author, and public speaker. Read more from this author